What Could be Done Further?
These are just random "brainstorming" type ideas
I've had that might improve things further at considerably less
cost. After dropping a huge chunk of change on what we just did, I'm
not inclined to rush out and spend more money. I'll probably spend
at least one winter just with this, just to see what the net effects
are. But if anyone has any suggestions, please contact me at:

1. Fix leaks. While we're pretty sure the total
insulation is good, there may be "cold spots" in the attic or
along the edges where the walls meet the ceiling of the house, or around
the edges of the doors and windows, where heat could leak through.
We could get this tested by having some insulation company come out and
test for cold spots using an infrared detection device.
2. Increase the R-value in the attic. We had
previously brought the attic up to R-50. For another $1000, we could
probably increase this to R-100. No idea whether this would do any
good. We originally added the attic insulation in the summer of
2006, and in the winter of 2006-7 did not notice any appreciable decrease
in heating requirement, but that may have been because the rest of the
house was so badly insulated.
3. Insulate the interior of the basement walls
maybe up to R-10 or R-15. I'm not sure what this would set us back
(another $10,000?), but it might enable us to survive the winter in the
basement with no heat at all.
4. Add storm windows. Since we missed our
opportunity to get R-9 windows, maybe this would help the main deficiency
in insulation right now. Of course with unlimited money, we'd just
replace the windows with the new R-9 type windows, but I'm thinking that
storm windows might do just as good a job.
5. (Feb. 2, 2009) Correct thermal bridging problem with
doorsteps. There is some thermal bridging in the thicker walls
themselves, because the wood framing intersects at certain points.
But there's another possibility, and that is that the doorsteps and back
porch constitute an opportunity for bridging as well. The doorsteps
are poured concrete directly attached to the concrete block / brick
mass. Wood
has an R-value of 1.25 per inch, but poured concrete has an R-value of
0.08. This may be the single best opportunity to improve the
insulation. I don't know exactly what materials to use instead of
concrete, though.
6. (Feb. 2, 2009) Is the air exchanger oversized?
Perhaps too much fresh air is cycling into the house. Thanks to
"lengould" of TheOilDrum.com
for making this suggestion.